Hiring a Home Contractor Without Regrets
By Oleksandr Potapenko · 2026-11-16 · How we research prices

The most expensive contractor is rarely the one with the highest quote. It is the one whose vague scope, missing permit or vanished deposit turns a three-week job into a three-month dispute. The Better Business Bureau (BBB) and HomeStars both report the same pattern year after year: most renovation complaints are not about craftsmanship at all, they are about contracts that never said what was actually included. This guide is the checklist that prevents that, built from the BBB's hiring advice, HomeStars' contractor-verification guidance and the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) renovation guides.
Start with three written quotes for the same written scope. Not three phone estimates, and not three quotes for three different versions of the job. Write one page yourself first: the rooms, the measurements, the materials and brands, who supplies what, who pulls the permit, and who hauls away the debris. Then hand that same page to every bidder. HomeStars and the BBB both stress this because it is the only way quotes become comparable: without a common scope, the cheapest bid is usually just the one that left the most out. A quote that is 30 percent below the others is not a bargain, it is a scope that is missing something expensive, and that something will reappear later as a change order.
Check the credentials before you fall in love with the price. Ask for the business registration, liability insurance certificate and workers' compensation coverage, and actually call the insurer to confirm the policy is current. In Ontario, the Construction Act gives you a specific tool most homeowners never use: a 10 percent holdback on every payment, held for 45 days after the work is substantially complete, which protects you if a subcontractor or supplier files a lien. Other provinces have similar holdback rules with different percentages and timelines, so check your province's construction lien legislation before you sign. A contractor who asks for half or more up front, or who will only take cash, is telling you how the job will end. A normal deposit covers materials, usually 10 to 15 percent, with the rest tied to milestones you can see and inspect.
References are worth more than a portfolio. Ask for three recent clients, and call all three, with the same questions: did the crew show up when promised, did the price move, and would you hire them again? Then drive past one finished job if you can. The BBB also recommends checking whether the business has a complaint history and how those complaints were resolved, because a company with ten complaints that answered all of them is often safer than a company with no record at all. Watch for the red flags that consumer-protection agencies list again and again: pressure to decide today, a price that is only valid if you sign now, a request to skip the permit to save time, no written warranty, and a contractor who subcontracts everything to day labour hired that morning.
The contract itself is where regret is made or prevented. CMHC's renovation guidance says a good contract names the start and finish dates, the payment schedule, the exact materials, the warranty length and what it covers, and who is responsible for permits and inspections. It should also say what happens when something changes: every change in writing, priced before the work starts, signed by both sides. Never pay the final instalment until the work passes inspection, the site is cleaned, and you have the lien waivers or the holdback period has run. If a dispute does arise, document everything in writing from day one, because provincial consumer-protection offices and small-claims courts decide cases on paper, not on memory. And before you sign anything, run the numbers through the RepairPrice home calculator (home-calculator.php) so you know whether the quote sits inside the fair range for your province, and read our companion guide "Handyman Hourly Rate in Canada" before you hand a small job to a general contractor at renovation prices.
Common questions:
Should I always take the lowest quote? No. Take the lowest quote among bids written against the same detailed scope, from contractors with verified insurance and references. A bid far below the others usually omits something that will be charged later as a change order.
How much deposit is normal for a renovation? Usually 10 to 15 percent for materials, with the rest paid at visible milestones. In Ontario you can also hold back 10 percent for 45 days after substantial completion under the Construction Act. Never pay half or more up front.
Do I need a permit for a basement finish or a bathroom? Almost always yes when walls, plumbing or electrical work move or are added. Your municipality issues the permit, and the contractor should pull it. A contractor who suggests skipping the permit is a contractor to walk away from.
What if the contractor disappears mid-job? That is what the milestone payment schedule and the holdback are for. Keep every payment, photo and message, contact your provincial consumer-protection office, and check whether your province's lien or home-warranty rules give you a claim.
| Check | Green flag | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Written scope | Materials, measurements, permits, disposal listed | Renovate bathroom, $12,000 with no detail |
| Payment | 10-15% deposit, milestone payments, 10% holdback (Ontario) | Half or more up front, or cash-only |
| Credentials | Registration, insurance, workers compensation verified | Cannot name three recent clients |
| Who does the work | Their own crew | Day labour hired that morning |
| Permits | Contractor pulls them | Skip the permit to save time |
| Quotes | Two or three pros, same written scope | Cheapest quote for a vague scope |