Cheapest Cars to Maintain in the USA
By Oleksandr Potapenko · 2026-11-16 · How we research prices

The cheapest car to maintain is rarely the cheapest car to buy — it is the one whose parts are cheap, whose repairs are simple, and whose design has been proven over millions of cars. RepairPal's data, built from millions of real repair orders at US shops, makes the gap concrete. A Honda costs $428 a year in repairs, a Toyota $441, and a Mazda $462. At the other end, a BMW costs $968 a year, an Audi $987, and a Porsche $1,192. The average car in the USA costs $652 a year, according to RepairPal. Over ten years, the difference between a Honda and a BMW is more than $5,000 — enough to buy another used car — and that is before you count the higher insurance and the dealer-only software that luxury ownership quietly adds.
The model-level numbers are even more useful than the brand averages, because they are what you actually shop for. RepairPal puts the Toyota Corolla at $362 a year — first of 36 compact cars — the Honda Civic at $368, the Toyota Camry at $388, the Honda Accord at $400, the Honda CR-V at $407, and the Toyota Prius at $408. CarEdge's ten-year projections tell the same story from the other direction: the Corolla at about $4,229 over ten years, the Camry at about $4,455, the Prius at about $4,156, and Toyota as a brand at about $5,996 — the cheapest gas brand to maintain, nearly $2,000 less than the next brand on its list. One figure in circulation does not fit: some roundups quote the Mazda3 at $286 a year, while RepairPal's own model data, as reported by CarBuzz and SlashGear, puts the Mazda3 at $433 a year. The $286 number appears to come from a narrower slice of the data, and the $433 figure is the one consistent with RepairPal's brand average of $462 for Mazda, so use $433 when you budget. The lesson is general: when two sources disagree, check which one matches the source's own brand-level data.
Why are Japanese brands so cheap to keep? Three reasons. First, parts: Honda, Toyota and Mazda sell in huge numbers, so aftermarket parts are everywhere and cheap. Second, simplicity: their mainstream models use proven engines and transmissions with few exotic parts. Third, reliability: they break less often in the first place, so the repair bill is smaller before the labour rate even matters. A Civic or a Corolla is not exciting, but it is cheap to own for a reason. The expensive end is not about bad engineering — it is about expensive parts and complex labour. A BMW or Audi needs the same oil change and brake pads, but the parts cost more, the labour takes longer because components are packed tighter, and many jobs need dealer-only software. A Porsche is the extreme case: low production numbers, performance parts and specialist labour. None of that makes them bad cars; it makes them expensive cars to keep.
The two big datasets agree on the cheap end but rank it differently, and the difference is instructive. Consumer Reports' 2025 Annual Auto Survey — owner-reported maintenance spending — puts Buick lowest of all brands at $5,260 over ten years, followed by Lincoln at $5,620 and Toyota at $5,950, with Hyundai at $6,110 and Tesla at $6,125. CarEdge, which models shop repair orders, ranks Toyota first. Consumer Reports captures what owners say they spent, including scheduled maintenance; CarEdge projects what repair orders actually cost, including unscheduled failures. A Buick owner who follows the schedule and never breaks down looks cheap in one dataset and ordinary in the other. Either way, the buyer rule is the same: the cheap list is Toyota, Honda, Mazda and the domestic brands that share their simple platforms, and the expensive list is European luxury.
The segment numbers help you compare across body styles. RepairPal data compiled by Autoblog puts compact SUVs at an average of $521 a year and midsize sedans at $526 a year — the two most popular segments in America are also among the cheapest to keep, which is no coincidence. And the dealer-versus-independent gap is where the money really leaks: Torque News analyzed a $2,038.98 maintenance quote handed to a 2024 RAV4 owner at the routine 30,000-mile mark — roughly 35% of CarEdge's entire ten-year maintenance estimate for the vehicle, spent in a single visit. That is the upsell list at work, and it is the reason the brand averages above assume a mix of dealer and independent work. Before buying your next car, look past the sticker price and check the annual maintenance cost for that exact model on RepairPal or the ten-year figure on CarEdge — it is the number that decides what the car really costs you. And before approving any single repair on the car you already own, check the fair price range for that job on your specific car in the RepairPrice calculator (calculator.php). The cheapest car to maintain is the one you already own and keep up with — but only if you are not overpaying for every repair along the way.
Common questions:
Q: What is the cheapest car to maintain in the USA? A: The Toyota Corolla, at $362 a year according to RepairPal — first of 36 compact cars — and about $4,229 over ten years according to CarEdge. The Honda Civic at $368 a year and the Toyota Prius at $408 a year are close behind. By brand, Honda is cheapest at $428 a year and Toyota second at $441 (RepairPal).
Q: What is the cheapest car brand to maintain? A: Honda at $428 a year in repairs, then Toyota at $441 and Mazda at $462, according to RepairPal. The average car costs $652 a year. Consumer Reports' 2025 survey ranks Buick lowest over ten years at $5,260, but that is owner-reported maintenance spending, while RepairPal and CarEdge model actual repair orders — both agree Toyota and Honda are at the cheap end.
Q: How much does the average car cost to maintain per year? A: RepairPal puts the average at $652 a year across all brands, covering scheduled maintenance and unscheduled repairs. AAA puts the blended national average for maintenance and repair at about $1,452 a year for a new car driven 15,000 miles — a different measure, because it includes the higher dealer-service costs of a new vehicle under warranty.
Q: Are luxury cars more expensive to maintain? A: Yes, by a wide margin. RepairPal puts BMW at $968 a year, Audi at $987 and Porsche at $1,192, against $428 for Honda — more than double. The gap is parts prices, tighter packaging that adds labour time, and dealer-only software, not bad engineering.
| Brand | Average repair cost (USD / year) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Honda | $428 | Cheapest to maintain; Civic, CR-V, Accord |
| Toyota | $441 | Corolla, Camry, RAV4; huge parts availability |
| Mazda | $462 | Mazda3, CX-5; simple, proven designs |
| Average car | $652 | RepairPal average across all brands |
| BMW | $968 | Parts and labour cost more; dealer software |
| Audi | $987 | Similar to BMW; complex packaging |
| Porsche | $1,192 | Most expensive mainstream brand to maintain |